RANKINGS: The Goyette Hitter Ranks

The following list is the culmination of my work on my personal hitter rankings.

Who? I’ve only ranked hitters, and I’ve only ranked hitters who have not made their MLB debut.

How does it work? It’s a heuristic ranking. Each hitter gets an overall score from 0-15. Points are awarded for:

Position: What defensive position is he likely to stick at in the MLB? 2 points for a SS or C, 1 point for a 2B, 3B, or OF, and 0 points for a 1B/DH.

Stats: Using our 5 digit ‘Blueberry’ ranking, award a hitter anywhere from 0-3 points based on his seasonal performance. The Blueberry is a 5 digit code which ranks a hitter by his percentile relative to the rest of the MiLB in the following categories: AVG-OBP-SLG-SB-AB. So Vlad’s Blueberry is 9-9-9-6-8. He’s 90th percentile or above in all of the slash-line categories, doesn’t run much so his SB is a 6, and he missed about a month with a knee injury, so his AB is an 8. In my big list of blueberry codes, a 9-9-9-6-8 season is worth 2 points.

Fantasy FV: Award 0-3 points for estimated future fantasy value using scouting reports. The method is described in more detail here.

Age-Level: Compare a player’s age relative to the highest level he played at, awarding 0 points if he’s too old for his level, 1 point if he’s the average age for his level, and 2 points if he’s young for his level.

ETA: Award 0 points if a player is a long way off from the MLB, 1 point if he’s 2 years out, 2 points if his expected MLB debut comes in the next 1.5 years.

Int.: Award 0-3 points for ‘intangibles’. Most players get 1 point. If a player has an injury, a bad attitude, or PED history, he gets 0 points. If a player is a ridiculous athlete, has a standout tool, or gets tagged by an evaluator that I respect as being ‘special’, he gets 2 points. If a player is Vlad Jr., he gets 3.

FarmRank: This is the player’s ranking on our seasonal hitter roto rankings, which can be found here. This rank is used as a tiebreaker for players within tiers. NOTE: It’s more important to consider which tier a player falls into, as opposed to where he falls within that tier. For example, don’t worry about where Royce Lewis, Fernando Tatis Jr., and Keston Hiura fall relative to each other. Just note that they’ve scored really well in the rankings, a tier above most of the other talent out there.

Rank Player Scoring Pos. Pts Stats Pts Fantasy FV Pts Age-Level Pts ETA Pts Int. Pts Org FarmRank
TIER ONE
1 Vladimir Guerrero Jr. 13 3B 1 99968 2 60 3 19-AAA 2 2019 2 +++ 3 TOR 4
2 Eloy Jimenez 13 OF 1 99909 3 60 3 21-AAA 2 2019 2 ++ 2 CWS 199
TIER TWO
3 Royce Lewis 12 SS 2 87899 2 60 3 19-A+ 2 2020 1 ++ 2 MIN 45
4 Fernando Tatis Jr. 12 SS 2 88998 2 60 3 19-AA 2 2020 1 ++ 2 SD 108
5 Keston Hiura 12 2B 1 88899 2 60 3 22-AA 2 2019 2 ++ 2 MIL 123
TIER THREE
6 Vidal Brujan 11 2B 1 99899 3 55 2 20-A+ 2 2021 1 ++ 2 TB 9
7 Nick Solak 11 2B 1 89899 3 60 3 23-AAA 2 2020 1 + 1 TB 42
8 Taylor Trammell 11 OF 1 78798 2 60 3 20-A+ 2 2021 1 ++ 2 CIN 233
9 Nick Senzel 11 3B 1 98985 2 65 3 23-AAA 2 2019 2 + 1 CIN 307
TIER FOUR
10 Wander Franco 10 SS 2 99977 2 55 2 17-A- 2 2023 0 ++ 2 TB 5
11 Gavin Lux 10 SS/2B 2 99999 3 50 1 20-AA 2 2020 1 + 1 LAD 11
12 Kevin Smith 10 3B/SS 2 98999 3 55 2 22-A+ 1 2021 1 + 1 TOR 17
13 Alex Kirilloff 10 OF 1 99969 3 55 2 20-A+ 2 2021 1 + 1 MIN 20
14 Nicky Lopez 10 SS 2 99799 2 50 1 23-AAA 2 2019 2 + 1 KC 27
15 Jo Adell 10 OF 1 88998 2 55 2 19-AA 2 2020 1 ++ 2 LAA 38
16 Yordan Alvarez 10 1B/OF 1 88978 2 55 2 21-AAA 2 2019 2 + 1 HOU 68
17 Bo Bichette 10 SS/2B 2 87899 2 55 2 20-AA 2 2021 1 + 1 TOR 96
18 Will Smith 10 C/3B 2 78978 1 55 2 23-AAA 2 2019 2 + 1 LAD 100
19 Adam Haseley 10 OF 1 98889 2 55 2 22-AA 2 2019 2 + 1 PHI 109
20 Carter Kieboom 10 SS 2 88889 2 55 2 20-AA 2 2020 1 + 1 WAS 133
21 Oscar Mercado 10 SS 2 87699 2 50 1 23-AAA 2 2019 2 + 1 STL 246
22 Brandon Marsh 10 OF 1 78799 2 55 2 20-A+ 2 2021 1 ++ 2 LAA 270
23 Austin Riley 10 3B 1 88949 2 55 2 21-AAA 2 2019 2 + 1 ATL 315
24 Daz Cameron 10 OF 1 77799 2 55 2 21-AAA 2 2019 2 + 1 DET 372
25 Jorge Mateo 10 SS 2 43599 0 60 3 23-AAA 2 2019 2 + 1 OAK 1,509
TIER FIVE
26 Luis Rengifo 9 2B 1 89899 3 45 0 21-AAA 2 2019 2 + 1 LAA 23
27 Tyler Freeman 9 SS 2 99997 2 55 2 19-A- 2 2022 0 + 1 CLE 32
28 Colton Welker 9 3B 1 99979 3 50 1 20-A+ 2 2021 1 + 1 COL 62
29 Nathaniel Lowe 9 1B 0 99949 3 50 1 23-AAA 2 2019 2 + 1 TB 69
30 Tyler Nevin 9 1B/3B 1 99978 2 55 2 21-A+ 2 2021 1 + 1 COL 75
31 Yusniel Diaz 9 OF 1 89898 2 50 1 21-AA 2 2019 2 + 1 BAL 90
32 Daulton Varsho 9 C/OF 2 88998 2 55 2 22-A+ 1 2021 1 + 1 ARI 93
33 Randy Arozarena 9 OF 1 78898 1 55 2 23-AAA 2 2019 2 + 1 STL 136
34 Ke’Bryan Hayes 9 3B 1 88889 2 55 2 21-AA 2 2020 1 + 1 PIT 144
35 Sean Murphy 9 C 2 88967 1 50 1 23-AAA 2 2019 2 + 1 OAK 226
36 Brendan Rodgers 9 2B/SS 1 76899 1 55 2 22-AAA 2 2019 2 + 1 COL 243
37 Jason Martin 9 OF 1 77899 2 50 1 23-AAA 2 2019 2 + 1 PIT 290
38 Andres Gimenez 9 SS 2 87799 1 55 2 19-AA 2 2020 1 + 1 NYM 311
39 Estevan Florial 9 OF 1 88898 2 55 2 20-A+ 2 2021 1 + 1 NYY 321
40 Peter Alonso 9 1B 0 89929 2 50 1 23-AAA 2 2019 2 ++ 2 NYM 361
41 Cristian Pache 9 OF 1 85789 0 60 3 19-AA 2 2020 1 ++ 2 ATL 641
42 Nick Gordon 9 SS/2B 2 64599 0 55 2 22-AAA 2 2019 2 + 1 MIN 958
43 Nick Madrigal 9 SS/2B 2 97585 0 55 2 21-A+ 2 2020 1 ++ 2 CWS 1,156
44 Luis Robert 9 OF 1 76596 0 60 3 20-A+ 2 2021 1 ++ 2 CWS 1,600
TIER SIX
45 Scott Heineman 8 OF 1 98899 3 40 0 25-AAA 1 2019 2 + 1 TEX 49
46 Ryan McKenna 8 OF 1 99889 3 45 0 21-AA 2 2020 1 + 1 BAL 54
47 Jacob Robson 8 OF 1 88899 2 45 0 23-AAA 2 2019 2 + 1 DET 127
48 Tucupita Marcano 8 2B/SS 1 99896 2 55 2 19-A- 2 2022 0 + 1 SD 129
49 Oneil Cruz 8 SS/3B 2 87988 1 50 1 19-A 2 2022 0 ++ 2 PIT 131
50 Blake Rutherford 8 OF 1 87899 2 55 2 21-A+ 1 2021 1 + 1 CWS 151
51 Evan White 8 1B 0 98879 2 60 3 22-A+ 1 2021 1 + 1 SEA 172
52 Khalil Lee 8 OF 1 79698 1 50 1 20-AA 2 2020 1 ++ 2 KC 414
53 Jahmai Jones 8 2B/OF 1 57699 0 60 3 21-AA 2 2020 1 + 1 LAA 553
54 Yu Chang 8 SS 2 66769 0 55 2 22-AAA 2 2019 2 0 CLE 702
55 Aramis Ademan 8 SS 2 34388 0 55 2 20-A+ 2 2021 1 + 1 CHC 1,874
TIER SEVEN
56 Harold Ramirez 7 OF 1 98999 3 50 1 24-AA 0 2020 1 + 1 TOR 44
57 Kyle Isbel 7 OF 1 99997 2 55 2 21-A 1 2022 0 + 1 KC 57
58 Josh Naylor 7 1B/OF 1 89879 2 45 0 21-AA 2 2020 1 + 1 SD 59
59 Jose Rojas 7 1B/2B 1 88988 2 40 0 25-AAA 1 2019 2 + 1 LAA 66
60 Eli White 7 SS 2 99899 3 45 0 24-AA 0 2020 1 + 1 OAK 80
61 Richard Palacios 7 2B 1 99975 2 55 2 21-A 1 2022 0 + 1 CLE 104
62 Andy Young 7 2B 1 88979 2 40 0 24-AAA 1 2019 2 + 1 STL 120
63 Geraldo Perdomo 7 SS 2 99896 2 35 0 18-A- 2 2022 0 + 1 ARI 132
64 Jacob Amaya 7 SS 2 99896 2 35 0 20-A 2 2022 0 + 1 LAD 134
65 Otto Lopez 7 UTIL 2 99896 2 35 0 19-A- 2 2022 0 + 1 TOR 139
66 Jarred Kelenic 7 OF 1 88896 2 50 1 19-R 1 2023 0 ++ 2 NYM 141
67 Lane Thomas 7 OF 1 76999 1 40 0 23-AAA 2 2019 2 + 1 STL 157
68 Matt Thaiss 7 1B 0 86889 1 50 1 23-AAA 2 2019 2 + 1 LAA 169
69 Drew Waters 7 OF 1 87999 2 50 1 19-A+ 2 2022 0 + 1 ATL 187
71 Pablo Olivares 7 OF 1 99887 2 40 0 20-A 2 2021 1 + 1 NYY 188
72 Joey Bart 7 C 2 88956 2 50 1 21-A- 0 2023 0 ++ 2 SF 227
73 Ryan Mountcastle 7 3B 1 87858 1 50 1 21-AA 2 2020 1 + 1 BAL 308
74 Jesus Sanchez 7 OF 1 86879 0 55 2 20-AA 2 2020 1 + 1 TB 313
75 Michael Chavis 7 3B 1 88965 1 50 1 23-AAA 2 2019 2 0 BOS 346
76 Freudis Nova 7 SS 2 96885 1 55 2 18-R 1 2023 0 + 1 HOU 382
77 MJ Melendez 7 C 2 66969 0 50 1 19-A 2 2022 0 ++ 2 KC 583
78 Isan Diaz 7 2B/SS 1 57799 0 50 1 22-AAA 2 2019 2 + 1 MIA 591
79 Monte Harrison 7 OF 1 55799 0 55 2 23-AA 1 2020 1 ++ 2 MIA 600
80 Myles Straw 7 OF 1 88599 1 45 0 23-AAA 2 2019 2 + 1 HOU 652
81 Jeisson Rosario 7 OF 1 78599 0 60 3 18-A 2 2022 0 + 1 SD 682
82 Jose Siri 7 OF 1 54898 0 60 3 23-AA 1 2020 1 + 1 CIN 723
83 Lucuis Fox 7 SS 2 77599 0 50 1 21-AA 2 2020 1 + 1 TB 739
84 Heliot Ramos 7 OF 1 55789 0 55 2 18-A 2 2022 0 ++ 2 SF 841
85 Keibert Ruiz 7 C 2 76708 0 50 1 20-AA 2 2020 1 + 1 LAD 845
86 DJ Peters 7 OF 1 55959 0 55 2 22-AA 2 2020 1 + 1 LAD 847
87 Mickey Moniak 7 OF 1 63578 0 55 2 20-A+ 2 2021 1 + 1 PHI 951
88 George Valera 7 OF 1 99942 1 55 2 17-R 1 2023 0 ++ 2 CLE 1,075
TIER EIGHT
89 Chad Spanberger 6 1B/DH 0 88999 3 50 1 22-A+ 1 2021 0 + 1 TOR 24
90 Jecksson Flores 6 UTIL 2 98899 3 40 0 24-AA 0 2020 1 0 KC 64
91 Ernie De La Trinidad 6 OF 1 99888 3 40 0 22-A+ 1 2021 0 + 1 MIN 71
92 Santiago Espinal 6 2B 1 88889 2 40 0 23-AA 1 2020 1 + 1 TOR 74
93 Jake Fraley 6 OF 1 99986 2 50 1 23-A+ 0 2021 1 + 1 TB 77
94 Jared Young 6 1B/OF 1 98989 3 40 0 23-A+ 0 2021 1 + 1 CHC 89
95 Cavan Biggio 6 2B 1 69999 2 45 0 23-AA 1 2020 1 + 1 TOR 92
96 JJ Matijevic 6 OF 1 77998 1 50 1 22-A+ 1 2021 1 + 1 HOU 102
97 Tyrone Taylor 6 OF 1 85999 1 40 0 24-AAA 1 2019 2 + 1 MIL 105
98 Jamie Westbrook 6 OF 1 87969 1 50 1 23-AA 1 2020 1 + 1 ARI 128
99 Rylan Bannon 6 2B/3B 1 79969 1 40 0 22-AA 2 2020 1 + 1 BAL 138
100 Nolan Jones 6 3B 1 89859 2 45 0 20-A+ 2 2021 0 + 1 CLE 219
101 Luis A. Basabe 6 OF 1 67899 0 50 1 22-AA 2 2020 1 + 1 CWS 228
102 Shed Long 6 2B 1 67799 0 55 2 23-AA 1 2020 1 + 1 CIN 279
103 Nolan Gorman 6 3B 1 88957 1 50 1 18-A 2 2022 0 + 1 STL 287
104 Corey Ray 6 OF 1 56999 1 55 2 23-AA 0 2020 1 + 1 MIL 302
105 Buddy Reed 6 OF 1 75899 0 55 2 23-AA 1 2020 1 + 1 SD 309
106 Jeter Downs 6 SS 2 67799 0 55 2 20-A 1 2022 0 + 1 CIN 333
107 Abraham Toro 6 3B 1 57889 0 50 1 21-AA 2 2020 1 + 1 HOU 364
108 LaMonte Wade 6 OF 1 68689 0 50 1 24-AAA 1 2019 2 + 1 MIN 430
109 Akil Baddoo 6 OF 1 57799 0 60 3 20-A 1 2022 0 + 1 MIN 441
110 Calvin Mitchell 6 OF 1 87869 1 50 1 19-A 2 2023 0 + 1 PIT 445
111 Esteury Ruiz 6 2B 1 66799 0 55 2 19-A 2 2022 0 + 1 SD 496
112 Lazaro Armenteros 6 OF 1 78787 0 55 2 19-A 2 2022 0 + 1 OAK 536
113 William Contreras 6 C 2 87848 0 50 1 20-A+ 2 2022 0 + 1 ATL 554
114 Tirso Ornelas 6 OF 1 67777 0 55 2 18-A 2 2022 0 + 1 SD 759
115 Will Benson 6 OF 1 36699 0 55 2 20-A 2 2022 0 + 1 CLE 988
116 Lucas Erceg 6 3B 1 65669 0 55 2 23-AA 1 2020 1 + 1 MIL 1,003
117 Leody Taveras 6 OF 1 55499 0 55 2 19-A+ 2 2022 0 + 1 TEX 1,016
118 Jeren Kendall 6 OF 1 44699 0 55 2 22-A+ 1 2021 1 + 1 LAD 1,103
119 Yasel Antuna 6 SS 2 44488 0 50 1 18-A 2 2022 0 + 1 WAS 1,668
120 Brendan McKay 6 1B/DH 0 ? 0 55 2 22-A+ 1 2021 1 ++ 2 TB 4,042
TIER NINE
121 Nathan Eaton 5 UTIL 2 99997 2 45 0 21-R 0 2023 0 + 1 KC 18
122 Dom Thompson-Williams 5 OF 1 88998 2 45 0 23-A+ 0 2021 1 + 1 NYY 22
123 Laz Rivera 5 2B 1 98999 3 40 0 23-A+ 0 2022 0 + 1 CWS 28
124 Alejandro Kirk 5 C 2 99956 2 45 0 19-R 0 2023 0 + 1 TOR 30
125 Grant Lavigne 5 1B 0 99986 2 55 2 19-R 0 2023 0 + 1 COL 31
126 Blaze Alexander 5 SS 2 99986 2 45 0 19-R 0 2023 0 + 1 ARI 33
127 Casey Golden 5 OF 1 88999 3 40 0 24-A 0 2022 0 + 1 COL 47
128 Brewer Hicklen 5 OF 1 88998 2 40 0 22-A 0 2021 1 + 1 KC 51
129 Taylor Walls 5 SS 2 99899 3 40 0 22-A 0 2023 0 0 TB 58
130 Zachery Almond 5 C 2 99956 2 40 0 22-A- 0 2023 0 + 1 ARI 65
131 Ronaldo Hernandez 5 C 2 87988 1 45 0 20-A 1 2022 0 + 1 TB 67
132 Luis Castro 5 1B 0 99986 2 40 0 22-A+ 1 2021 1 + 1 COL 83
133 David Fry 5 C 2 99957 2 40 0 22-A 0 2022 0 + 1 ARI 87
134 Bret Boswell 5 2B/3B 1 87989 2 40 0 23-A+ 0 2021 1 + 1 COL 91
135 Chavez Young 5 OF 1 88999 2 40 0 21-A 1 2022 0 + 1 TOR 106
136 Leandro Cedeno 5 1B/OF 1 99956 2 40 1 20-R 0 2023 0 + 1 STL 117
137 Brock Deatherage 5 OF 1 99996 2 45 0 22-A+ 1 2021 0 + 1 DET 124
138 Cody Thomas 5 OF 1 88979 2 40 0 23-A+ 0 2021 1 + 1 LAD 154
139 D’Shawn Knowles 5 OF 1 99986 2 45 0 17-R 1 2023 0 + 1 LAA 221
140 Trevor Larnach 5 OF 1 99965 2 45 0 21-A 1 2022 0 + 1 MIN 362
141 Brent Rooker 5 OF 1 66879 0 50 1 23-AA 1 2020 1 + 1 MIN 395
142 Micker Adolfo 5 OF 1 88857 1 50 1 21-A+ 2 2022 0 0 CWS 424
143 Hudson Potts 5 3B 1 66869 0 50 1 19-AA 2 2022 0 + 1 SD 460
144 Xavier Edwards 5 SS 2 99795 1 45 0 19-A- 1 2022 0 + 1 SD 524
145 Zack Collins 5 C/DH 1 59779 0 50 1 23-AA 1 2020 1 + 1 CWS 545
146 Tristen Lutz 5 OF 1 55789 0 55 2 20-A 1 2022 0 + 1 MIL 602
147 Jonathan India 5 3B 1 58875 0 55 2 21-A 1 2022 0 + 1 CIN 762
148 Jordan Groshans 5 SS/3B 2 87826 0 50 1 18-R 1 2023 0 + 1 TOR 923
149 Bobby Bradley 5 1B 0 45849 0 45 0 22-AAA 2 2019 2 + 1 CLE 1,006
150 Ronny Mauricio 5 SS 2 75756 0 50 1 17-R 1 2023 0 + 1 NYM 1,153
151 Kyle Lewis 5 OF 1 55748 0 55 2 23-AA 1 2020 1 0 SEA 1,316
152 Brett Cumberland 5 C 2 47748 0 50 1 23-AA 1 2020 1 0 BAL 1,408
153 Jhailyn Ortiz 5 OF 1 44658 0 50 1 19-A 2 2022 0 + 1 PHI 1,483
154 Wander Javier 5 SS 2 INJ 0 55 2 19-R 0 2023 0 + 1 MIN 4,000
155 Luis Garcia 5 2B/SS 1 ? 0 50 1 18-A+ 2 2021 0 + 1 WAS ?
TIER TEN
156 Niko Decolati 4 OF 1 99997 2 40 0 21-R 0 2023 0 + 1 COL 8
157 Cal Stevenson 4 OF 1 99996 2 45 0 21-R 0 2023 0 + 1 TOR 15
158 Mariel Bautista 4 OF 1 99996 2 45 0 20-R 0 2023 0 + 1 CIN 16
159 Drew Avans 4 OF 1 89996 2 45 0 22-A 0 2022 0 + 1 LAD 26
160 Matt Cogen 4 OF 1 99966 2 40 0 23-A 0 2022 0 + 1 LAD 43
161 Jake Scheiner 4 3B/1B 1 88989 2 40 0 23-A 0 2022 0 + 1 PHI 53
162 Drew Mount 4 OF 1 98977 2 40 0 22-R 0 2023 0 + 1 CIN 60
163 Jim Haley 4 1B/3B 1 98997 2 40 0 23-A 0 2022 0 + 1 TB 76
164 Daniel Robinson 4 OF 1 99886 2 40 0 21-R 0 2023 0 + 1 LAD 78
165 Jarren Duran 4 OF 1 99997 2 40 0 22-A 0 2022 0 + 1 BOS 81
166 Luis Santana 4 2B 1 99986 2 35 0 19-R 0 2023 0 + 1 NYM 85
167 Coco Montes 4 2B/3B 1 99987 2 40 0 21-R 0 2023 0 + 1 COL 86
168 Tanner Nishioka 4 3B 1 99977 2 40 0 23-A 0 2022 0 + 1 BOS 98
169 Jonah Davis 4 OF 1 99976 2 40 0 21-R 0 2023 0 + 1 PIT 103
170 Vince Fernandez 4 1B/DH 0 78989 1 50 1 23-A+ 0 2021 1 + 1 COL 107
171 Niko Hulsizer 4 OF 1 79985 1 40 0 21-R 0 2023 0 ++ 2 LAD 118
172 Diosbel Arias 4 2B/3B 1 99976 2 40 0 22-A- 0 2022 0 + 1 TEX 119
173 Michael Helman 4 2B 1 99985 2 40 0 22-A 0 2022 0 + 1 MIN 126
174 Tony Pena 4 OF 1 99974 2 40 0 20-R 0 2023 0 + 1 TB 137
175 Roberto Ramos 4 1B 0 78979 1 40 0 23-AA 1 2020 1 + 1 COL 149
176 Jared Oliva 4 OF 1 77898 1 40 0 22-A+ 1 2021 1 0 PIT 182
177 Taylor Jones 4 1B 0 88969 2 40 0 24-AA 0 2020 1 + 1 HOU 255
178 Pavin Smith 4 1B 0 67769 0 55 2 22-A+ 1 2021 1 0 ARI 551
179 Austin Beck 4 OF 1 86689 0 50 1 19-A 2 2022 0 0 OAK 732
180 Kevin Maitan 4 3B/SS 1 54657 0 55 2 18-R 1 2023 0 0 LAA 1,558
TIER ELEVEN
181 Jose Caballero 3 2B/3B 1 88897 1 40 0 22-A 0 2022 0 + 1 ARI 35
182 Curtis Terry 3 1B 0 99947 2 40 0 21-A- 0 2022 0 + 1 TEX 94
183 Hunter Stovall 3 2B 1 96966 1 40 0 22-R 0 2023 0 + 1 COL 143
184 Daniel Reyes 3 OF 1 88996 1 40 0 22-A- 0 2022 0 + 1 DET 147
185 Peter Maris 3 SS 2 78977 0 40 0 24-AA 0 2020 1 0 TB 245
186 Julio Pablo Martinez 3 OF 1 78897 1 45 0 22-A- 0 2023 0 + 1 TEX 330
187 Everson Pereira 3 OF 1 76665 0 45 0 17-R 1 2023 0 + 1 NYY 1,548
188 Jordyn Adams 3 OF 1 78674 0 45 0 18-R 0 2023 0 ++ 2 LAA 1,726
189 Alec Bohm 3 3B 1 66465 0 50 1 22-A- 0 2023 0 + 1 PHI 2,035
190 Kyler Murray 3 OF 1 NCAAF 0 45 0 NA 0 2023 0 ++ 2 OAK 4,000

I’d love your feedback on this project. Who is high, who is low? Who is missing? What’s ridiculous? Let me know!

The beauty of this ranking method is that it’s wide open to tweaking. Assign your own extra ‘intangible’ points to guys who you think deserve it. Ding a guy on intangibles because you didn’t like his lack of hustle down the line. Give points to guys in good organizations. Take away points from guys in the Rockies org. Weigh scouting 2x as much as stats. Don’t worry about defensive positions at all. Whatever you want to do, feel free to tweak it for your own uses.

This ranking will grow and change as time goes on. As players get their 2019 assignments that will change things. As hitters are hot or stumble out of the gate their stats points will move accordingly. As new scouting info comes in hitters will be adjusted up or down. But for this particular snapshot in time, I’m standing by these ranks!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *