2018 1st-team All-American out of Pepperdine. Raised eyebrows with a big-time performance in the wood bat WCL in 2017. Good athlete who was a 2-way player in college. Will need to reign in the swing-and-miss in his game, which will continue to get exposed as he moves up the ladder. He’s a watchlist guy for me right now. Let him slide in the draft and follow what he does in Full Season ball in 2019.Read More 2018 FARMHAND CROP: Jordan Qsar
Pioneer League Mid-Season All-Star rebounded from a tough spring with a strong pro debut this summer. College shortstop who played primarily in RF this year, could also handle 3B duties. He’s a quick, strong, well-coordinated athlete. Big questions about his hit tool, but his K-rate was palatable this year. If his hit tool lets him tap into his raw power, he’s a potential sleeper.Read More 2018 FARMHAND CROP: Niko Decolati
Dodgers’ 33-round choice signed for $5k out of Southeast Lousiana. Stats and video scouting show that there is a hit tool lurking here. He’s got the ability to hit for enough power to punish mistakes. He’s probably not going to be a CF in professional ball, but range and arm are good enough for the OF. Was excellent on the basepaths in his pro debut as well. He’s got a 4th OF profile, but there’s a non-zero chance that he makes it to the majors.Read More 2018 FARMHAND CROP: Drew Avans
College bat who posted an eye-popping .511 OBP in his first taste of professional ball. Might lack the power to play a corner OF spot. His best path to fantasy relevance is to continue to be an OBP machine with good SB success rates. Eric Longenhagen of Fangraphs has noted that the Blue Jays have had success with this type of profile. Ryan Noda comes to mind. Worth a late draft flier.Read More 2018 FARMHAND CROP: Cal Stevenson
Won Pioneer League MVP award, hit 2 HR in the Pioneer League/Northwest League All-Star Game. Questions about defensive position, as he spent more time at 2B (28 games) and 3B (24 games) last year than SS (13 games). Hit tool is glitchy, swing needs work. Strong enough to flash oppo power, but the hit tool is holding him back at this point. Looks like a potential fringe-plus runner. There are some tools lurking in his profile, but he’s at best a late-round flier in FYPD at this point.Read More 2018 FARMHAND CROP: Coco Montes
A recent Twitter discussion we were in revolved around just how much weight an owner can put on Rookie or Short-Season statistical performances. Any scout will tell you that you cannot rely on stat lines to evaluate a player’s performance. There are many pitfalls in the stats. Small sample size mirages. Wide gaps in run-scoring environments, official scoring decisions, and even playing surfaces within leagues. And even bigger gaps in talent, especially in the Rookie leagues where teams can struggle to find competent pitchers and catchers to put on the field.Read More DIGGING DATA: Scouting and Statlines
The following list is the culmination of my work on my personal hitter rankings.
Who? I’ve only ranked hitters, and I’ve only ranked hitters who have not made their MLB debut.
How does it work? It’s a heuristic ranking. Each hitter gets an overall score from 0-15. Points are awarded for:Read More RANKINGS: The Goyette Hitter Ranks
KC’s other pitcher selected out of U of F, Kowar possesses a fringe-plus fastball/changeup combo that works together well. Needs the curveball to develop into a viable plus offering. Command and control are lagging so far in his professional debut, but workload (112.0 college innings this year) could be a factor. A risky profile, but the changeup is a real weapon.Read More 2018 FARMHAND CROP: Jackson Kowar
Mariners have loved Gilbert since his stellar 2017 Cape Cod League performance, but his fastball velocity was down a few ticks since then. Will need to sharpen and have more confidence in his secondary offerings as he moves up the ladder. Feel for pitching and repeatable mechanics give him a shot as a big-league rotation piece, but right now it’s hard to see Gilbert as more than a backend starter. However, if the velocity comes back and the secondaries improve, there is some upside.Read More 2018 FARMHAND CROP: Logan Gilbert
Fiery starter with a big time FB (touches 99) which he struggles to control. Looks like a boom-or-bust type of starter at this point in his career. Needs to improve command and both secondary offerings to have a shot to stick in the rotation. There is a wide variance of outcomes here. He could lock everything down, improve his secondaries, and have SP2 upside. Or, he could just be LOOGY who walks too many guys and gives up too many HRs. There are also health concerns with his delivery (despite the fact that he’s already underwent TJS). If you draft McClanahan, be prepared to take on risk.Read More 2018 FARMHAND CROP: Shane McClanahan