| Rank | Name | Team | ADREIP | NFC ADP | Min Pick | Max Pick |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Josh Hader | MLW | 0.401 | 59.76 | 29 | 93 |
| 2 | Aroldis Chapman | NYY | 0.295 | 85.06 | 48 | 122 |
| 3 | Roberto Osuna | HOU | 0.371 | 90.10 | 25 | 127 |
| 4 | Kirby Yates | SD | 0.378 | 76.80 | 37 | 117 |
| 5 | Kenley Jansen | LAD | 0.227 | 119.32 | 63 | 185 |
| 6 | Liam Hendriks | OAK | 0.336 | 104.45 | 55 | 150 |
| 7 | Ken Giles | TOR | 0.334 | 130.81 | 77 | 206 |
| 8 | Taylor Rogers | MIN | 0.232 | 115.31 | 68 | 177 |
| 9 | Edwin Diaz | NYM | 0.088 | 123.56 | 70 | 197 |
| 10 | Brad Hand | CLE | 0.158 | 119.01 | 73 | 186 |
| 11 | Hector Neris | PHI | 0.270 | 138.86 | 78 | 208 |
| 12 | Brandon Workman | BOS | 0.267 | 161.24 | 93 | 278 |
| 13 | Hansel Robles | LAA | 0.231 | 169.10 | 94 | 299 |
| 14 | Raisel Iglesias | CIN | 0.124 | 146.21 | 87 | 215 |
| 15 | Craig Kimbrel | CHC | -0.211 | 146.87 | 83 | 256 |
| 16 | Nick Anderson | TB | 0.283 | 186.59 | 67 | 418 |
| 17 | Alex Colome | CWS | 0.177 | 161.47 | 103 | 280 |
| 18 | Jose Leclerc | TEX | 0.029 | 175.50 | 103 | 297 |
| 19 | Keone Kela | PIT | 0.103 | 214.14 | 101 | 389 |
| 20 | Archie Bradley | ARZ | 0.038 | 177.27 | 118 | 311 |
| 21 | Ian Kennedy | KC | 0.141 | 203.54 | 130 | 361 |
| 22 | Joe Jimenez | DET | 0.034 | 218.06 | 135 | 398 |
| 23 | Giovanny Gallegos | STL | 0.320 | 206.83 | 113 | 374 |
| 24 | Mark Melancon | ATL | 0.203 | 226.89 | 133 | 374 |
| 25 | Will Smith | ATL | 0.248 | 171.31 | 93 | 342 |
| 26 | Sean Doolittle | WAS | 0.061 | 202.97 | 66 | 353 |
| 27 | Daniel Hudson | WAS | 0.088 | 338.70 | 175 | 463 |
| 28 | Seth Lugo | NYM | 0.240 | 356.07 | 200 | 428 |
| 29 | Diego Castillo | TB | 0.184 | 460.83 | 225 | 538 |
| 30 | Hunter Harvey | BAL | -0.041 | 437.57 | 177 | 581 |
| 31 | Mychal Givens | BAL | 0.100 | 341.11 | 184 | 562 |
| 32 | Wade Davis | COL | -0.134 | 375.49 | 179 | 719 |
| 33 | Brandon Kintzler | MIA | 0.131 | 407.05 | 179 | 749 |
| 34 | Scott Oberg | COL | 0.203 | 301.28 | 182 | 446 |
| 35 | Ryan Helsley | STL | 0.033 | 597.60 | 193 | 750 |
| 36 | Tony Watson | SF | 0.109 | 455.11 | 197 | 733 |
| 37 | Emilio Pagan | SD | 0.303 | 291.28 | 99 | 521 |
| 38 | James Karinchak | CLE | 0.581 | 494.44 | 264 | 562 |
| 39 | Ryan Pressly | HOU | 0.431 | 454.96 | 241 | 544 |
| 40 | Aaron Bummer | CWS | 0.313 | 560.57 | 243 | 619 |
| 41 | Yoshihisa Hirano | SEA | 0.127 | 552.09 | 190 | 748 |
| 42 | Drew Pomeranz | SD | 0.380 | 523.26 | 235 | 626 |
| 43 | Corey Knebel* | MLW | 0.135 | 508.32 | 229 | 578 |
| 44 | Dellin Betances* | NYM | 0.230 | 463.11 | 214 | 720 |
| 45 | Blake Treinen | LAD | -0.015 | 444.71 | 212 | 540 |
| 46 | Jose Alvarado | TB | 0.019 | 573.82 | 251 | 705 |
| 47 | Matt Magill | SEA | 0.085 | 436.67 | 205 | 704 |
| 48 | Matt Barnes | BOS | 0.130 | 533.68 | 222 | 672 |
| 49 | Tyler Rogers | SF | 0.375 | 715.91 | 181 | 750 |
| 50 | Robert Stephenson | CIN | 0.235 | 655.51 | 355 | 707 |
| 51 | Zack Britton | NYY | 0.351 | 585.87 | 201 | 669 |
| 52 | Adam Ottavino | NYY | 0.083 | 598.74 | 235 | 702 |
| 53 | Jordan Hicks | STL | 0.287 | 650.54 | 207 | 750 |
| 54 | Sergio Romo | MIN | 0.195 | 612.00 | 230 | 704 |
| 55 | Trevor May | MIN | 0.191 | 588.18 | 262 | 632 |
| 56 | Kevin Ginkel | ARZ | 0.250 | 575.18 | 235 | 720 |
| 57 | Ty Buttrey | LAA | 0.134 | 608.40 | 294 | 746 |
| 58 | Oliver Drake | TB | 0.179 | 744.70 | 487 | 750 |
| 59 | Rafael Montero | TEX | 0.218 | 619.62 | 317 | 750 |
| 60 | Colin Poche | TB | 0.185 | 682.31 | 364 | 722 |
| Rank | Name | Team | ADREIP | NFC ADP | Min Pick | Max Pick |